eTestor
Cognitive & Intelligence

Critical Thinking Test

Assumptions, conclusions, evidence and flawed reasoning

Take the Test

Free · No account

Critical Thinking Test: A hand circling a chart on a printed report with a red pen at a meeting table, sticky notes, a closed laptop and an eTestor mug

What is a critical thinking test?

A critical thinking test checks how well you judge an argument on its merits: what it takes for granted, what really follows from the facts, what evidence would make it stronger or weaker, and where the reasoning goes wrong. Each question gives you a short everyday argument and asks one of those four things. Graduate recruitment tests and admissions tests often include critical reasoning questions like these. This one has 48 questions, and your total score is in the full report.

About this test

Four areas, twelve questions each: Assumptions (what an argument takes for granted without saying so), Conclusions (what must be true, or is best supported, given the facts), Weighing evidence (which new fact would most strengthen or weaken an argument) and Reasoning flaws (the mistake in an argument, such as treating a coincidence as a cause). Every question is a short everyday scene, a bakery, a school, a council meeting, with four options. Each area starts easy and gets harder.

What you'll discover

  • Assumptions

    Finding the unstated idea an argument needs in order to work.

  • Conclusions

    Seeing which conclusion the facts support, and which goes further than they do.

  • Weighing evidence

    Judging which new fact would strengthen or weaken an argument most.

  • Reasoning flaws

    Naming what is wrong with a line of reasoning, in plain words.

Understanding the Critical Thinking Test

This critical thinking test has 48 questions in four areas of twelve: assumptions, conclusions, strengthening and weakening arguments, and reasoning flaws. Each question is a short argument about everyday life, a shop, a school, a workplace, and asks one thing about it. Each area starts easy and gets harder, and there is no time limit. Your total score is in the full report, which also scores each area.

Here is the kind of question you'll meet (not from the test). A café owner says: "We put up a new sign in May, and sales rose 20%. The sign worked." What does that assume? That nothing else that changed in May explains the rise. A fact that would weaken it: a large office opened across the street in May. A fact that would strengthen it: sales at the two cafés next door, with no new sign, stayed flat. And the flaw, if the owner stops there: treating one thing that came before a change as its cause.

Critical thinking has no single agreed definition, but judging an argument apart from whether you like its conclusion is at its core. Keith Stanovich and Richard West asked 349 college students to rate arguments about real-life issues. How well they could rate an argument's quality regardless of their own beliefs was linked to cognitive ability, and also to a habit of open-minded thinking, which mattered even after ability was taken into account (Journal of Educational Psychology, 1997, doi:10.1037/0022-0663.89.2.342). It can be taught: a review of 341 effects found an average gain of 0.30 standard deviations from instruction, with discussion, real problems and mentoring among what helped (Abrami and colleagues, Review of Educational Research, 2015, doi:10.3102/0034654314551063). This is our own test: the questions are original, written and checked by our team, and two reviewers solved every one without the key and agreed with every answer. It has no norms yet, so your score is not a percentile.

Where the Critical Thinking Test comes from

Critical thinking has no single agreed definition, but most definitions include analyzing arguments, weighing evidence and drawing only the inferences it supports. Keith Stanovich and Richard West (1997) studied a core part of it, evaluating arguments independently of prior belief, and found it linked both to cognitive ability and to actively open-minded thinking. Identifying assumptions, drawing conclusions, weighing evidence and spotting flaws are common question types in critical reasoning assessments. This test is our own construction in that tradition, with original questions written and checked by our team; it is not a published instrument.

How the Critical Thinking Test is scored

Four areas of twelve questions (assumptions, conclusions, weighing evidence and reasoning flaws), each scored as the number correct (0 to 12), plus a total out of 48. With four options per question, guessing alone averages 12 of 48. Two reviewers solved every question without the key and agreed with every answer. The test has no norms yet, so scores are not percentiles. A meta-analysis of 341 effects found that instruction raises critical thinking by about 0.30 standard deviations on average (Abrami and colleagues, 2015).

Questions people ask

Is the critical thinking test free?

Taking the test is free, with no account needed: just your email at the end. Your total score is part of the paid report. Every score, the written analysis and the certificate are in the full report: $1.99$2.41 in the first 30 minutes after you finish, $3.99$4.83 after that, or included in eTestor Unlimited.

What are critical reasoning questions?

Short arguments followed by one question: which assumption the argument depends on, which conclusion the facts support, which new fact would most strengthen or weaken it, or what its main flaw is. They test how you judge reasoning, not what you know, so everything you need is in the text. The common traps are an answer that is true but beside the point, and one that goes further than the facts allow.

Is critical thinking the same as intelligence?

Related, not the same. In Stanovich and West's 1997 study, cognitive ability helped people judge arguments fairly, but a separate habit, being willing to weigh evidence against your own views, predicted it too. That is why a very able person can still reason badly about a topic they care about.

Can you improve critical thinking?

Yes. Across 341 effects from teaching studies, instruction raised critical thinking by about 0.30 standard deviations on average, and discussion, real problems and mentoring helped (Abrami and colleagues, 2015). On your own, the best practice is asking the same three questions of every argument you read: what does it take for granted, what would change my mind, and does the conclusion go further than the facts?

What is a good score on a critical thinking test?

Each question has four options, so guessing alone averages 12 of 48. Above 24 means you got most of the easier questions in every area; 40 or more means you got most of the hard ones too. We don't have norms yet, so read these as rough guides, not percentiles.

Is this the critical thinking assessment test employers use?

No. Employers buy critical thinking assessments from specialist publishers, each with its own questions, time limits and norms. The question types here are the common ones, so it is useful practice, but your score won't carry over as a number. Most employer tests are timed and this one isn't, so when you practise for one, set yourself a time limit.

Ready to find out?

Free to take, no account needed. Your result is in the full report.